Plan Commission Meeting — Agenda Packet

1 PC 6/9/2026 Common Council Chambers – City Hall Room 100 7325 W. Forest Home Ave., Greenfield, Wisconsin PLAN COMMISSION STAFF REPORT Tuesday, June 9, 2026 – 6:00 p.m. 1. Roll Call. 2. Approval of the Minutes from the May 12, 2026 meeting. 3. Discussion regarding last Common Council meeting. 4A. Special Use Permit for an expansion of Game Together MKE, an existing used merchandise store, to be located at 4635 S. 108th St., submitted by Steven Barron d/b/a Game Together MKE. (Tax Key No. 609-0033-001) 4B. Site Review for an expansion of Game Together MKE, an existing used merchandise store, to be located at 4635 S. 108th St., submitted by Steven Barron d/b/a Game Together MKE. (Tax Key No. 609-0033-001) Items 4A and 4B may be considered together or separately. Overview and Zoning The applicant, Steven Barron, has operated Game Together MKE, a used merchandise store focused on buying and selling used video games, consoles, accessories, and collectibles, in Suite 8 located at 4635 S. 108 St. for a little over two years. The tenant space immediately adjacent to their suite has recently been vacated, and the applicant would like to expand their business into that space as well. The original tenant space is approximately 1,475 sq. ft., within the Omega Plaza Shopping Center multi-tenant commercial building. The additional space they wish to add would double their footprint in the building. 2 PC 6/9/2026 The property is zoned C-4 Regional Business District, which permits used merchandise stores as a Special Use. Since this is a new use in this tenant space, a public hearing and a new Special Use Permit are required. A public hearing can be scheduled as early as July 21, 2026. The proposed hours of operation would be Sunday through Thursday, 10am-8pm, and Friday and Saturday 10am – 12am (midnight). The current hours of operation are Wednesday through Saturday, 11am-7pm, Sunday 10am-4pm, and closed on Mondays and Tuesdays. Site Review A site plan was not submitted, but the Zoning Code allows for the comprehensive review of the condition of the site as part of the Plan Commission review. There is an approved site and landscape plan on file from 2019. The site was most recently reviewed when BodywoRx appeared before Plan Commission in April 2026. Lighting, HVAC/Utility Box Screening, Fencing, Signage, Parking Area, and Landscaping: No proposed changes. Engineering Comments: N/A Overall, the site remained unchanged from the Staff’s previous site visit. Existing location Proposed expanded location 3 PC 6/9/2026 Driveway Area: The southern driveway approach to this property is in a state of disrepair. The entrance has been noted in previous site reviews but has not yet been addressed. The Fire Marshall, Mike Wist, has spoken with property management for Omega Shopping Center and they stated that the delay in replacing the entrance was caused by an issue with a contractor. However, the property owner has confirmed that they are in the process of getting a contract signed to have the driveway approach and sidewalk replaced by November 1, 2026. The proposed Game Together MKE requires fifteen (5 spaces per 1,000 sq. ft.) parking spaces and the remaining building requires 63 (5 spaces per 1,000 sq. ft.) parking spaces, for a grand total of 78 parking spaces. A total of 69 stalls are provided on the property. The Common Council may waive the shortage. Staff recommends approval and that this item be scheduled for the July 21, 2026 Common Council meeting. Recommendation: Recommend Common Council approval of the Special Use Permit and Site Review for an expansion of Game Together MKE, an existing used merchandise store, to be located at 4635 S. 108th St., submitted by Steven Barron d/b/a Game Together MKE. (Tax Key No. 609-0033-001), subject to Plan Commission and Staff comments, and the following conditions: (Item 1 is required to be satisfied by November 1, 2026). 1. Repair of the southern driveway entrance to the property. If the owner cannot or will not be able to make the repair by that deadline, they may enter into an agreement with the City for the City to complete the work. Such an agreement would be created and executed in conjunction with the City Attorney. 4 PC 6/9/2026 5. Site and Landscape Plans for a parking lot redesign for the CITGO Gas Station, located at 4715 S. 27th St., submitted by Bilal Amjad, d/b/a Ali’s Investments. (Tax Key No. 622-9999-000) Overview The applicant, Bilal Amjad, d/b/a Ali’s Investments, is proposing to upgrade the existing landscaping and add three new parking stalls to the property. The Plan Commission approved a Special Use Review for this property in December 2025, which included an ownership change and a switch from BP to CITGO. The property is zoned C-3 Highway and Commercial Service Business District. Site and Landscaping Plan The purpose of this proposal is to provide additional parking stalls and improve visibility of the monument sign. The applicant is proposing to remove two trees on the north lot line to create three additional parking spaces. Additionally, the applicant is proposing to remove four (4) existing trees along the east lot line and install all new landscaping. The landscaping plan is under review with the City Forester. The proposed parking lot redesign results in 25 parking stalls, including one (1) ADA stall. 5 PC 6/9/2026 Lighting, HVAC/Utility Box Screening, Fencing, and Signage: No proposed changes. Recommendation: Recommend Common Council approval of the Site and Landscape Plans for a parking lot redesign for the CITGO Gas Station, located at 4715 S. 27th St., submitted by Bilal Amjad, d/b/a Ali’s Investments. (Tax Key No. 622-9999-000), subject to Plan Commission and Staff comments. (Item 1 is required to be satisfied prior to the issuance of any permits associated with the proposed work. Contractors applying for permits should be advised accordingly.) 1. Approval of the submitted landscaping plan, by the City Forester. 6. Site, Landscaping, and Architectural Plan Review for Tuckaway Heights Apartments, located at 5470 S. Tuckaway Ln., submitted by Matthew Stasik, d/b/a Point Real Estate Management, LLC (Tax Key No. 645-9999-005) The applicant, Matthew Stasik, d/b/a Point Real Estate Management, is proposing to install a fenced-in dog park area in one of the open spaces on the multi-family apartment property. Additionally, he is proposing to upgrade the exterior of the existing proposed (3 new spots) existing proposed 6 PC 6/9/2026 resident amenity area, including adding turf for bag toss games, a more defined seating area, and adding an outdoor grill area. Use of both the outdoor amenity area and the dog park will be limited to between the hours of 8:00am and 10:00pm daily. Dog Park Area The applicant is proposing to install a 30ft x 95ft dog park enclosure in the open greenspace area located in the northern portion of the property. The enclosure will include a dog waste station within the fenced area and two entrances. The fence will be 4-ft black vinyl-coated chain link, which matches the existing fencing along a few borders of the property. The purpose of creating a dog park area is to improve safety by separating pets from other open areas, to organize the common open space while maintaining an open, visual character, and to create a designated, enclosed area for residents and their dogs. proposed existing 7 PC 6/9/2026 Resident Outdoor Amenity Space The applicant is also proposing to invest in an outdoor amenity space for residents of the apartment complex. In the area behind the leasing office, they are proposing to add a turf recreation area that can accommodate bocce ball and bag toss, an outdoor seating area, decorative lighting, and a gas grilling area and firepit. Historically, the area had provided a community pool. However, the pool was removed between 2015 and 2016. When the pool was removed, it was replaced with grass and a maple tree. The location of the amenities behind the leasing office building places higher-activity, utility-dependent features away from residential building frontages, improving overall site compatibility. The addition of café lighting will allow for security and visibility while minimizing glare and light spillover onto adjacent properties or W. Grange Ave. Landscaping Plan No trees will be removed related to the installation of the dog park area, and no additional landscaping will be added. A single maple tree will be removed to existing proposed 8 PC 6/9/2026 accommodate the outdoor amenity space. Staff have received a plant list for the outdoor amenity space but have not yet received a full landscaping site plan. Once Staff receive the full landscaping plan, it will be provided to the City Forester for review and approval. Staff recommends that this item be expedited to the June 16, 2026 Common Council meeting. Recommendation: Recommend Common Council approval of the Site, Landscaping, and Architectural Plan Review for Tuckaway Heights Apartments, located at 5470 S. Tuckaway Ln., submitted by Matthew Stasik, d/b/a Point Real Estate Management, LLC (Tax Key No. 645-9999-005), subject to Plan Commission and Staff comments, and the following conditions: (Item 1 is required to be satisfied prior to the issuance of any permits associated with the proposed work. Contractors applying for permits should be advised accordingly.) 1. Submittal of a landscaping plan to the Community Development Division for approval by the City Forester. 7A. Special Use Review for Mezcalero Food Truck, a proposed food truck business, located at 6869 W. Forest Home Ave., submitted by Juanita Campos, d/b/a Mezcalero Restaurant and Bar (Tax Key No. 571-8957-002) 7B. Site Review for Mezcalero Food Truck, a proposed food truck business, located at 6869 W. Forest Home Ave., submitted by Juanita Campos, d/b/a Mezcalero Restaurant and Bar (Tax Key No. 571-8957-002) Items 7A and 7B may be considered together or separately. Overview & Zoning The applicant, Juantia Campos, d/b/a Mezcalero Restaurant and Bar, is proposing to expand their previously-approved food truck home base special use from two 9 PC 6/9/2026 food trucks to three trucks. The original Special Use for the food truck home base was approved by Plan Commission in August 2025 and Common Council in September 2025. The property is zoned C-2 Community Commercial District, which regulates food truck home bases as a Special Use. Since this use has already undergone the public hearing process during the Special Use Permit review, it can be expedited to the June 16, 2026 Common Council agenda. Site Review A site plan was not submitted, but the Zoning Code allows for the comprehensive review of the condition of the site as part of the Plan Commission review. During the 2025 site review, several issues were noted. The dumpsters were not inside the enclosure, items were located around the dumpster and rear door, and additional screening had been added to the patio area. None of these issues were present during the site visit. Parking Area The three food trucks will occupy five parking spaces on the south side of the building. Previously, only three spots had been dedicated to food trucks. Lighting, HVAC/Utility Box Screening, Fencing, Signage, , and Landscaping: No proposed changes. Engineering Comments: N/A Staff recommends that this item be expedited to the June 16, 2026 Common Council meeting. 10 PC 6/9/2026 Recommendation: Recommend Common Council approval of the Special Use Review and Site Review for Mezcalero Food Truck, a proposed food truck business, located at 6869 W. Forest Home Ave., submitted by Juanita Campos, d/b/a Mezcalero Restaurant and Bar (Tax Key No. 571-8957-002), subject to Plan Commission and Staff comments. 8. Community Development Report. 9. Adjournment.