08-10-26 Historic Preservation Commission Packet

HISTORIC PRESERVATION COMMISSION AGENDA Menomonie City Hall 800 Wilson Avenue Garden Level, Room 58 5:00pm Monday – August 10, 2026 Page 1 of 1 1. Roll Call 2. Approval of Minutes for July 13, 2026 – discussion and possible action. 3. Public Comments (agenda items only). 4. New Business a) Certificate of Appropriateness application from MPOC, LLC for painting of the exterior north wall at 420 Main Street East – discussion and possible approval. b) Initial Consultation regarding potential repairs or improvements at 424 Main Street East – discussion only (no action). 5. Confirm Next Meeting Date – discussion only (no action). 6. Adjourn “PUBLIC ACCESS” NOTE: Upon reasonable notice, efforts will be made to accommodate the needs of individuals with disabilities. For additional information or to request the service, contact the City Clerk or the City Administrator at 715-232-2221. MEMORANDUM David Schofield, Director of Public Works dschofield@menomonie-wi.gov 715-232-2221 Ext.1020 1 TO: Historic Preservation Commission FROM: David Schofield, Director of Public Works SUBJECT: Staff Comments DATE: August 10, 2026 Historical Preservation Commission Meeting Agenda Item #2 – July 13, 2026 Minutes The draft July 13, 2026 minutes are attached. If the Commission concurs, the appropriate motion would be Approve the minutes for the July 13, 2026 meeting, as presented (simple majority). Agenda Item #3 – Public Comments The public is invited to provide comments regarding agenda items only. Agenda Item #4A – COA for painting the exterior north wall at 420 Main Street East Enclosed in the packet is a Certificate of Appropriateness application submitted by Wade Lambrigtsen on behalf of MPOC, LLC for painting the exterior north wall at 420 Main Street East. The proposed painting is in compliance with all building inspection codes. Because the building is in the Historic District, the Historic Preservation Commission must review and approve. If the Commission concurs, the appropriate motion would be Approve the Certificate of Appropriateness application from MPOC, LLC for painting of the exterior north wall at 420 Main Street, as presented (simple majority). Agenda Item #4B – Initial Consultation regarding potential repairs or improvements at 424 Main Street East City Staff received the attached inquiry from Gideon Bernthal regarding 424 Main Street East. Mr. Bernthal is considering purchasing the building and wishes to determine if the Historic Preservation Commission has any concerns about his proposed work on the property. If Mr. Bernthal purchases the property, he would submit an application for a Certificate of Appropriateness at a later date. This item is presented for discussion only. No action can be taken at this time. Agenda Item #5 – Next Meeting Date The next meeting, if required, will be September 14, 2026. This item is presented for discussion only. No action can be taken at this time. HISTORIC PRESERVATION COMMISSION MEETING MINUTES Public Works Director Schofield called the Historic Preservation Commission to order on July 13th, 2026 at 5:08 pm in City Hall in Garden Level Room 58. Members present were Leland Schwebs, Melissa Kneeland, John Sobota, Sylvia Gengenbach, and Carl Rudenborg. Joshua Kohnke and Tim Dotseth were absent. Also, present were David Schofield, Dave Kowieski, Christopher Johnson, and John Goetz. Appointment of Chairperson pro Tempore: Commission Chairperson Joshua Kohnke was absent, as such a temporary chairperson was needed, for this meeting only. Motion to appoint Melissa Kneeland as Chairperson pro tempore for this meeting made by Sobota; Gengenbach 2nd; motion carried unanimously on a voice vote. Approval of Minutes: Motion to approve the minutes of the June 8, 2026 meeting by Schwebs; Rudenborg 2nd; motion carried unanimously on a voice vote. Public Comments: John Goetz, from Lumber Jax spoke on the proposed material for the knee-wall, having brought a sample of the proposed non-mortar stone façade. Giving a brief description of the materials, their water resistance, and ease of installation – as the faux stone comes on sheets which are fastened to the wall with screws into backing board, which overlap each other as the material is built up the wall. Question was raised about the repairability of the material, by Rudenborg. Which was stated as repairable, by Kowiski, but that comes with having to remove of the stacked portion. Old Business: none. New Business: a) Certificate of Appropriateness application from Lumberjax Ventures, LLC for Façade Renovation at LumberJax BakeHouse and Café (230 Main Street East) The project was summarized as presented in the packet by City Staff; this is the resubmission for only the previously excluded knee-wall. Concern was raised about the installation and the possibility for open looking joints in the panels by Schofield. Assurance was given that the contracted builder would take care in the installation. Motion to approve the Certificate of Appropriateness application from Lumberjax Ventures, LLC for Façade Renovation at LumberJax BakeHouse and Café (230 Main Street East), as presented made by Schwebs; Sabota 2nd; motion carried unanimously on a voice vote. The next regular Historic Preservation Commission meeting will be held on Monday August 10th, 2026 at 5:00pm at City Hall, Room 58. Motion to adjourn made by Rudenborg; Gengenbach 2nd; motion carried unanimously on a voice vote; meeting adjourned, at 5:16 pm. Chris Johnson, Deputy City Clerk Certificate of Appropriateness (COA) City of Menomonie receipt of an application for Certificate of Appropriateness, the Menomonie Historic Preservation Commission met on the date identified below and took action on the application. In taking action on the application, the Commission gave consideration to the criteria listed in Title 2 Chapter 8 of the Menomonie City Code entitled "HISTORIC PRESERVATION COMMISSION" and the standards contained in any applicable district plan. The following shall be submitted to the office of Downtown Menomonie, 800 Wilson Ave Menomonie, WI 54751, Seven (7) business days prior to the meeting date of the Historic Preservation Commission: 1. Two (2) copies of the photographs of all exterior building elevations taken perpendicular to the building, one copy to be placed in the Historic Preservation Commission archives. 2. Submit one (1) set of photographs when project is complete to be placed in archives. If applicant permits, Historic Preservation Commission will use photos for a press release to local newspaper. 3. Hard line drawings which convey house the project will look when completed. 4. Colors from the approved color palette shall be indicated on the drawings. 5. Building materials proposed to be used shall be indicated on the drawings. 6. If the project involves restoration or cleaning, submit description of work, procedures, and extent of work. 7. If a sign is to be lit, provide a description and photocopy of fixture. Applicant's Name: MONTE BURSTAD Business Name (If applicable): MPOC, LLC. Addres: 117 MAIN ST. EAST Phone Number of Applicant: 715-556-2208 Name of the historic property/landmark (if known): Address of the property/landmark: 420 MAIN ST. EAST Select the reason for the Certificate of Appropriateness: Alteration to an existing property/landmark o New Construction Ο Demolition Specify the colors from the historical color pallet to be used: HC-163 PUXBURY GDEY He-190 BLACK BENTANN MOORE, 138 NOVA GOLD Specify the materials to be used: BEN MOORE & NOVA COLOR PAINT Provide a description of the work to be done: RE-PAINT TOP OF BUILDING HC-163 FAINT DECOBATIVE PIECES & 1883"-138 GOLD, PAINT WINDOW TRIM HC-19O BLACk If the COA is for signate please address the following. Please attach a sketch or rendering of the sign. Be sure to include the names of the historical appropriate colors used and where on the sign each color will go. All changes done wo the exterior of your property must be approved by the Historic Preservation Commission prior to the start of any work. Message on the sign: Background color(s): H6-163 DUXBURY GOEY Lettering colors(s): TRIM- HC-190 BLACK Font Style Name: Letter Size: Will this sign require new lighting? No Overall dimension of the sign: Name and Phone number of the Project Contact Person (If different than above) VINTAGE SION SHOP-WADE LAMBRIETSEN- 579-1840 I hereby certify that I understand the conditions of approval required by the Historic Preservation Commission and that the project will be completed as approved by the Commission. In addition, I agree to notify the city about changes proposed in the project prior to commencing such work and understand that if deemed necessary by City staff, that the proposed changes will be forwarded to the Contmission for further review. ne ta peit foe Date: 7-29-26 Signature of Owner or Verified Property Manager:Date: 7.29.26 Re-paint top portion of building Benjamin Moore HC-163 Duxbury Grey Paint raised embelishments and '1883' date 138 Nova Gold/ Paint all window trim and area above awning Ben Moore HC-190 Re-paint columns on building Benjamin Moore HC-163 Duxbury GreyVinta SIGN SH Historic Preservation Commission, I am considering purchasing the property located at 424 Main Street in Menomonie. I currently own and operate a business similar to the one presently located in the building. Before moving forward with the purchase, I would like to better understand the Historic Preservation Board's expectations regarding the restoration of the property. The building has fallen into significant disrepair, and I want to ensure that I will be able to make the repairs necessary to preserve it without encountering unexpected requirements that could make the project financially unfeasible. My intent is to restore the building as closely as possible to its original appearance. I do not intend to make changes that would significantly alter its historic character or architectural features. Based on my initial observations, the building's gutters are filled with dirt and vegetation, which has allowed water to pool on the roof. This has led to deterioration of portions of the façade and has directed water onto the window sills, resulting in water intrusion and rot. The moisture has also caused deterioration of the mortar in several areas. To address these issues, I anticipate the need to: • Replace deteriorated sections of the façade with materials that match the existing appearance. • Replace the gutters and add downspouts to properly direct water away from the building. • Repair or repoint deteriorated mortar where necessary. • Repair or replace rotted window sills with materials that match the original design. • Repaint repaired areas to match the building's existing appearance. I am not seeking formal approval through this letter. Rather, I am hoping to determine whether the Board would have any general objections to these types of one-for-one restoration repairs, or whether there are specific preservation requirements I should be aware of before purchasing the property. I am committed to preserving this historic building rather than changing it. At the same time, I am not a large commercial developer, and the building also has significant interior repairs that will require substantial investment. Before proceeding with the purchase, I would simply like to understand whether the proposed restoration work would generally be supported and whether there are additional requirements I should anticipate. I appreciate your time and any guidance you can provide. Thank you for your consideration, and I look forward to your response. Sincerely, Gideon Bernthal